Showing posts with label VT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label VT. Show all posts

Thursday, April 14, 2022

Burlington Sidewalks are "Shared Paths"

 
Burlington Sidewalks are “Shared Paths”—Aim for Ped Only
                                Sidewalks!

    —The differences: North Ave Plan, Champlain Parkway and
     Parkway RIGHTway

Confusion exists on what is a sidewalk, a bikeway and a shared-use path here in Burlington.

Actually with only one exception all Burlington sidewalks are shared-use paths as bikes are allowed to travel there along with pedestrians.  As a senior most of my bike riding has been on sidewalks as there are practically no protected bike lanes (cycle track) yet in the City.  Streets with painted bike lanes are not safe in general, and prohibitively unsafe for less skilled and older/younger cyclist who all are consigned to the sidewalk system.

Note we can exclude here any discussion of the Burlington Bikepath and similar pathways.  The Bikepath is a recreation path—it is not a transportation facility, a facility marked by being lit and maintained year round.

The one exception in the City to bicyclist use of sidewalks technically are the adjacent streets of the Marketplace, South Winooski Ave from Pearl to Main Streets, Main St from South Winooski Ave to Saint Paul St, Saint Paul St from Main St to Bank St, Pearl St from Saint Paul St to South Winooski Ave. Add to this the Marketplace itself, though cyclists do use the Marketplace in the early a.m. when service vehicles and trucks are allowed from Pearl St to Main St.




      North Avenue Plan (2014) Creates the Mold

While not intended, the North Avenue Plan (North St to Plattsburgh Ave) created the mold of how to define the role of sidewalks and bike accommodations on our City streets. With a goal of “highest safety for all modes” the Plan calls for cycle track end-end-to-end along with a separate sidewalk while employing safest-for-all-modes roundabouts at key intersections.  Cycle track would be in the form of a 5 foot wide lane on each side of the Avenue with either a curb or other physical separation from the vehicle lanes.  

What was not discussed by the Advisory Committee in the North Avenue plan process or the plan document was the implication that cyclists would with few exceptions would be expected to use the cycle track and the sidewalk—instead of being shared-use—becomes a dedicated pedestrian sidewalk.  The term used in addition to “complete” street in accordance to the Vermont complete streets statute during the North Ave plan was “equality street.”  Equality street described each mode—pedestrian, bicycle and motor vehicle—being provided its own dedicated, safe, mobility space.  

So when the cycle track and roundabouts complete the renewal, nay transformation, of North Avenue the sidewalk there is no longer “shared-use” but dedicated pedestrian space with cycling mostly prohibited.

    Champlain Parkway/Champlain RIGHTway and Shared-use

The grassroots Pine Street Coalition arose in 2015 while the Burlington Walk Bike Council reviewed reviewed the complete lack of basic walk and bicycle accommodation in the Champlain Parkway design.  Pine Street adopted the reasoning of the Walk Bike Council and in 2016 the Walk Bike Council endorsed the Pine Street “Redesign Guidelines.”  

The Pine Street design, now its “Champlain RIGHTway” (RIGHTway) design features a dedicated two-way bikeway and sidewalk from Queen City Park Rd through to Kilburn Street/Curtis Lumber, about two miles.  Pine Street and the Vermont Racial Justice Alliance (VRJA) position on the current design of the Parkway is leave Pine Street from Kilburn Street to Main Street alone, and instead bypass King Maple via the railyard to Battery Street Extension, now the $20 million federally funded Rail Enterprise Project (REP).  Pine Street and VJRA RIGHTway extends the sidewalk and dedicated bikeway along the REP to connect to the Bikepath at Maple St.

In addition to the dedicated bikeway, RIGHTway recommends additionally cycle track along the Parkway route.

What has not generally recognized is the RIGHTway dedicated two-way bikeway means no pedestrians!  And the RIGHTway sidewalk adjacent the bikeway does not allow cyclists!  This design approach copies the mold first set in the 2014 North Avenue Plan.

The RIGHTway approach follows the highest level of safety approach in the North Avenue Plan, a “complete” and “equality” for all modes street.  This mirrors the new US Department of Transportation Roadway Safety System Strategy, our national Vision 0 approach to no serious and fatal injuries.  The national strategy requires addressing racial and low income equity and climate change as part and parcel of safety infrastructure investments. The strategy includes a “Safe System Approach” and “Safe System Intersections” when investing in roads and streets.  The point here is that the current Parkway “shared-use path” pales in comparison to a dedicated sidewalk and dedicated two-way bikeway in RIGHTway.  

         Pedestrian and Bicycle Classification

There is no readily available pedestrian and bicycle facility classification in general use today.

A sidewalk classification might be: Class 1—Pedestrian Only and Class 2—Pedestrian Shared Use.  For cycling: Class 1—Bicyclist Only (bikeway or cycle track) and Class 2—Bicyclist Shared with pedestrians.

Intersections are critical for safety, the roundabout being the standard as it cuts serious and fatal injuries by about 90%.  The only other intersection which provides equivalent safety is the all-way stop.  Signals are to be considered only where a roundabout is unfeasible.


Tony Redington
Walk Safety Advocate
TonyRVT99@gmail.com






 




Tuesday, March 1, 2022

Convert Most Unsafe Vermont Communuty Street to Safest with Roundabouts

 September 1, 2021 Rev. 3 February 28, 2022


Convert Most Unsafe Vermont Communuty Street to Safest with Roundabouts



Historic Old North End North Street: Low Cost Conversion of the Most Unsafe and DangerouS  Vermont Community Street to Vermont’s Most Safe, Low Speed, Pedestrian Friendly Street!


                                                  Summary 


One thing parents well know, there is no safe route to Sustainability Academy/Barnes Elementary School along North Street in Burlington. 


This policy analysis recommends mini roundabouts along Vermont’s most unsafe and dangerous street right here in Burlington—North Street from North Avenue to the west to North Union to the east with five of six cross intersections on the state’s high crash list of 111 statewide. The roundabout is the only intersection type on the Federal Highway short list of pedestrian safety “proven countermeasures.” A mini roundabout, is the most likely application in most of the North Street intersections meaning about one injury crash per intersection every few years versus 0.6 injuries per year per intersection now in the most recent tabulation. North Street roundabouts might approach the record of the other five downtown roundabouts of one injury per 50 years (half century) per intersection. And injuries at a roundabout are less severe than at signals. Right now the five high crash intersections total expanded to a decade of an estimated 32 injuries compares to one injury per decade tabulated at the five downtown roundabouts!


The five Vermont downtown roundabouts with the 52 years of data in Manchester Center {3}, Middlebury and Montpelier averaged just one injury per decade—0.8 car occupant injury, 0.2 pedestrian injury, 0.0 bike injury—none serious. Roundabouts can be expensive as costly utility work often is involved in a project unrelated to the roundabout itself. However, with mini roundabouts used where there are right-of-way constraints, a factor present on North Street, the mini can often be installed with the same safety performance of the bigger sibling for as little as $50,000.  The mini roundabout cost is in the neighborhood of traffic calming.  It is not far from the cost of three sets of one concrete cylinder flower pot and two white plastic stakes ($17,000) installed at several Burlington intersections. Besides you do not have to tend to the flowers at a mini roundabout! 

 

pastedGraphic.png



For the historic Old North End (ONE) dating from the early 19th century, North Street remains the most active community centered street featuring numerous retail, business and institutional land uses. Sustainable Academy (Barnes) Elementary School is just a block from the now Old North End Community Center, formerly Saint Joseph’s Elementary School. A variety of restaurants, convenience stores, residential buildings, ethnic retail markets,Vantage Press, Dion Locksmith and Bissonette Properties, as well as the locked Elmwood Cemetery are all found between along North Street between North Avenue and North Union Street. As well, there are four high crash intersections—all four cross intersections located between North Avenue (west terminus of North Street) and North Union Street to the east. Of the six intersections North Avenue, Park Avenue, North Champlain Street, Elmwood, North Winooski and North Union Street are on the VTrans latest high crash intersection list—the only cross intersection along the stretch not on the State list? Elmwood/Intervale and Park Avenue both considered a problem intersection in the neighborhood. 

North Street Important Demographics A key to understanding the dilemma of North Street lies in great part to the unusual demographics of Burlington. In a state with 71% of households owning their home and 29% renters, Burlington is almost the opposite 36% owning their home, 64% renter households. VT Speaker of the House Jill Krowinski and Rep. Curt McCormack who has headed the House Natural Resources and Transportation Committees represent the poorest in the City including practically all the ONE and some of King Maple neighborhoods which contain the only census tracts with excess of 80% with low and moderate incomes, King Maple with the highest concentration of persons with brown and black skins in the state—and the 30% representative district households have no car access and therefore are pedestrian and transit dependent for their transportation. The safety on streets like North Street is absolutely essential. In fact Burlington overall has 26% of its households with poverty level incomes with King Maple and ONE along with Winooski (29% of households with poverty level incomes) together representing the historic economic engine of Vermont, now a corridor of poverty. (A poor family of four means a weekly income at most of about $500.) North Street—Site of Many Injury and Non-injury Vehicle Crashes The four high crash intersections in a five year period averaged 3.8 injuries a year all four intersections in five years (19 injuries all four intersections over five years) plus 3.2 reportable fender bender crashes (“Property Damage Only” or PDO) (64 all four intersections PDO crashes in five years). See table 1. North Street clearly is a victim of the growth of the New North End (NNE) which sent increasing numbers of vehicles destined for downtown, mostly via North Ave, Park Avenue and North Champlain Street. North Winooski and North Union intersections carry the historic traffic continuing today between downtown Burlington and Winooski, a route dating from the days of Ethan and Ira Allen. 


The North Winooski Avenue-Riverside Avenue was not only the Allen’s era route, it was the route of the first trolley line built in the 1880s and continued in operation until 1929. With North Street featuring four of just 111 high crash intersections in the Vermont list, clearly it is a prime candidate for being the most unsafe and dangerous community street in Vermont! ONE leaders have been concerned about safety along North Street. It was a discussion item act the Arts and Business Network ( https://www.oneabn.org/ ) several years ago but it had to wait in line for the Winooski Corridor study now completed. In 2020 a Department of Public Works draft plan included a demonstration of a mini roundabout at the high crash North St/No. Winooski Ave intersection along with a second at Decatur/No. Union/No. Winooski. That demonstration was cancelled for the current construction year from lack of funds, reportedly, and a Public Works representative said there is no consideration of a North Street corridor study. 


Why Traffic Signals which Generate Crashes, Congestion and Delay? All five cross intersections along the west end of North Street (North Ave, Park Ave, North Champlain and Elmwood/Intervale, and North Winooski) are signalized while North Union is a three-way, all-way stop (North Union is one way northbound). Historically as vehicle traffic surged post World War II urban streets quickly became locations of congestion and the only choice to relieve the congestion which handled more traffic than simple signs: the now ubiquitous traffic signal. Traffic engineers had little choice as traffic increased, the traffic signal or limitless congestion and endless queues. But there was a price to shifting from signs to signals—injury crashes increase, particularly for the vulnerable—those who walk and bike—would increase as would car occupant injuries. 


Prime factors in increased injuries and crashes—signals versus all way stop intersections, for example—include higher speeds of vehicles traveling through on green and vehicle which fail to stop which cause, for example, the deadly T-bone crash. For pedestrians the high speeds at signals contribute to the 20% higher pedestrian casualty rate at signals versus all-way stop control and equally safe roundabouts (source, FHWA). So, careful protocols were established to minimize the tradeoff of safety and mobility, called signal “warrants.” This was the status of traffic management until the advent of the modern roundabout which began to make its appearance in the United States (and Vermont) in the 1990s, getting its start in 1966 in the U.K. While slow to become the standard it is today, NY State Department of Transportation and two Canadian Provincial Ministries of Transport (British Columbia and Alberta), for examples adopted regulatory “roundabouts first” policies between 2005 (NY) and 2010. A U.S. Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) definitive study in 2001 determined American roundabouts cut serious and fatal injuries by “about 90%.”


A half century of Vermont downtown roundabouts found a single pedestrian injury (not serious), four non-serious car occupant injuries and 0 bicyclist injuries. Consider the five injuries in a half century of service for downtown Vermont roundabouts versus four North Street intersections generating 3.8 injuries a year! As important the stunning tabulation this year of record of now 9,000 roundabouts in US and Canada has yet to experience a single pedestrian death on a marked roundabout crosswalk!  This compares to Burlington during just the the 1998-2020 period at just 75 signalized intersections, 2 pedestrian hit in crosswalks were killed (Barrett St crossing at Dominos and Shelburne Street crosswalk at Home Ave). 


As important, Burlington, Vermont and the nation have been falling behind in road safety to a terrible degree. When the first roundabout in the US was built in 1990, the US and UK were safest in road fatalities per mile of travel in the world—UK still remains at the top—while the US has dropped to 18th with 21,000 pandemic level of excess road deaths yearly. Even in covid 2020 when travel miles dropped 12%, fatalities per mile of travel increased 8%! As concerning is the trend since 2010 in pedestrian deaths—up 50% with Hispanics 50% more likely to die per population than white, Black people almost twice that of white-non-Hispanic. 


The two Burlington pedestrian deaths during 2010-2021 (and continuing in 2021) contributed to the upturn in national pedestrian deaths—up 46% in the latest reports. The US Congress, states’ transportation departments and metropolitan planning organizations like Vermont single one, Chittenden County Regional Planning Commission (CCRPC) are well aware of the dismal road death pandemic and in 2013 U.S. laws required all federally funded highway projects to reduce fatal and serious injuries, mandating state and CCRPC to adopt five year objectives for reductions, revised during subsequent five year intervals. Unfortunately for Federal Highway Administration as well as most states and metros (including VTrans and CCRPC) with about two years of the first five year reduction targets in face of the surge of deaths and serious injuries in 2020 while vehicle miles declined 13%, most all will likely fail their first five year targets! 


Note that all neutral and advocate groups for safety—American Automobile Association (AAA), American Association of Retired Persons (AARP), Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and GEICO—have as first on their list or near the top of actions for safety, the installation of roundabouts and conversion of existing traffic signals to roundabouts. The new Vermont road death factor: an estimated 22 deaths per year from long term exposure to allowed tailpipe admissions. While road fatalities in recent years about 60 per year, we have learned recently in University of North Carolina research that there is another set of road deaths directly related to long term exposure to tailpipe emissions. ( https://ie.unc.edu/2021/06/08/new-study-identifies-leading-source-of-health-damages-from-vehicle-pollution-in-12-states-and-washington-d-c ). As a summary of the report states: “states experienced substantial health impacts from vehicle emissions and can gain health benefits from local action.” The recent study involving a number of northeastern US state identified the numbers by state and the annual loss of life in Vermont, 22 deaths, expands the annual Vermont road death number by about a third to about 80 deaths yearly. 


While electric cars, hopefully, will be the dominant vehicle type years from now, certainly for a generation the long term deaths from internal combustion cars will continue to exact a toll on Vermonters. It is very likely that built up urban areas—like Burlington’s ONE and King Maple neighborhoods—with congestion and vehicle delay causes a higher level of long term exposure fatalities than living and/or working in a country setting in Charlotte. Since roundabouts cut intersection emissions from vehicles up to one third, the roundabout aids in reducing the pollution load to residents and workers in our admittedly congested city streets. 


An Affordable Investment Quickly Makes North Street a Model of a Safe Community Street —Applying the lessons learned from the AARP Vermont Pine Street Workshop (2014) and Environmental Justice Process in the Champlain Parkway (2019 to date)


First and foremost the North Street intersections in question are best served by roundabouts, likely a mini roundabout like Vermont’s first and only one in Manchester Center. The mini roundabout has the same, or even better, safety record for all modes. Second, any consideration of roundabouts along North Street needs to have all six intersections evaluated in a reasonably short corridor study—the study is not to make signals better, it is to establish roundabout feasibility and utilize experienced (read national practitioners) as part of the consultant team. Actual design of roundabouts for the corridor could be done in a matter of weeks, certainly within a 12-month period. 


An analysis of 5-year and 1-year injury and "Property Damage Only" (PDO) crashes at the five North Street intersections is instructive. This can be calculated easily from the 5-year recent VTrans High Crash Location Report series, 2012-2016. The cost of a fatality used is $1.5 million, $88,500 for an injury and $11,300 for a PDO. Since mini roundabouts are cheap, crash cuts and injury cuts (72% injury cuts alone) with an overall well over $1 million for all five intersections in a year more than covers the five intersections made walkable and safe!  This ignores the real benefits of tens of thousands of hours of reduced vehicle and pedestrian delay (real dollars for business trip delay), stress on all users, and increased economic activity enabled for nearby businesses. Add to this the traffic signal caused excessive climate heating emissions and the now known 25 yearly estimated Vermont deaths from a lifetime of vehicle exhaust pollutants.   









Table 1: Vermont Agency of Transportation High Crash Location Report 2012-2016 Data on the Five North Street Burlington State High Crash Intersections


#23 [Place on list of 111 Vermont high crash intersection list—1 worst, 111 least worst] North St/North Champlain St 0.220 [intersection name and milepost] 5 years/21 crashes/5 injuries/17 PDO [years of data recorded, total crashes, total injuries, property only crashes {PDO}] ($30,219–estimated cost per crash); Total Crashes (per year): 21(4.25); Total estimated crash cost for 5 years: $635,000 ($126,900 per year) 


#40 Park St/North St 0.280 5 years/19 crashes/4 injuries/16 PDO ($28,147\–estimated cost per crash); Total Crashes (per year): 19 (3.8); Total estimated crash cost for 5 years: $535,000 ($107,000 per year)


#46 North Winooski (Alternate 7)/North St 1.620 5 years/19 crashes/3 injuries/16 PDO ($23,489–estimated cost per crash); Total Crashes (per year): 19 (3.8); Total estimated crash cost for 5 years: $446,000_($89,200 per year) 


#87 North Union St/North St 0.300 5 years/15 crashes/0 injuries/15 PDO (3-way-stop) ($11,300–estimated cost per crash) Total Crashes (per year): 15 (3.0); Total estimated crash cost for 5 years: $170,000_($34,000 per year)


#110 North Ave/North St 0.180 5 years/20 crashes/4 injuries/17 PDO ($27,305 estimated cost per crash) Total Crashes (per year): 20 (4.0);  Total estimated crash cost for 5 years: $546,100 ($109,220 per year)



Cost really is not a significant factor as roundabouts at the five high crash intersections would certainly reduce crash/injury costs by about half in a five year period, a $2,177,000 value based on half the total cost estimates, above. A set of roundabouts would likely cost as little as $50,000 each, certainly far less than $2,177,000 million. As analyzed elsewhere a roundabout replacing a high crash intersection on the 20 Burlington intersections in the VTrans list would conservatively result in one less injury per year, a saving of $88,500 and two less PDO crashes, a saving of $22,600—or $111,100 per converted intersection per year. An installation of a mini roundabout on a high crash North Street intersection would easily be paid for in savings in about a year, assuming about $50,000 base cost for a roundabout. Some of those savings are to police department costs of incident management, reports, etc., and other City savings include the trips by emergency equipment and personnel to crashes and then to UVMMC. 

Table 2: Summary Data on All Five North Street High Crash intersections (2012-2016) 


Total Crashes 90 total all five intersections:


18.0 crashes per year all five intersections


3.6 crashes per intersection per year —16 injuries in five years, 3.2 injuries per year all five intersections, 0.64 injuries per year per intersection


84 property damage only (PDO) crashes, 16.8 PDO crashes per year all five intersection, 3.4 per PDO crash per intersection per year


Total estimated crash cost for 5 years all four intersections: $2,177,000 ($435,000 per year), $87,000 per intersection per year


Note: There are many crashes involving no injury which never “reportable,” i.e., never enter the crash counts by police departments and the state.  If estimated total crash is $3,000 or below, no reports are necessary. 


  


Tony Redington February 28, 2022 TonyRVT99@gmail.com

Tuesday, September 28, 2021

Roundabouts the Intersetion Standard, RRFBs not a Substitute

Locust Street—Roundabouts on Both Ends of Street? 

Next June we all know a roundabout gets going on the east end of Locust Street, a street home of a church, a church school and a major city playground. Two of the three Three Sisters streets go north from Locust along with another popular residential street, Hayward. The street slopes down slowly from east to west with a rather sharp decline approaching its west end on Pine Street with Parkside Terrace on the north corner and Callahan Park on the southside, a bus shelter on the east side perhaps about 100 feet south of the intersection. Callahan Park also continues a north/south pedestrian way for students who travel to and from Champlain School. 

Somehow, Locust Street either end has intersections with major change in the last decade. But are they the right changes? And what do the changes mean to safety, particularly for pedestrians? Pedestrians remain the "apartheid mode" with few efforts at high quality safety transportation investments to benefit the pedestrian, more often than not in our urban areas a person of color. 

We all walk but few bike!) Also, somehow, the west intersection of Locust, a T junction, is largely untouched by the Champlain Parkway, either in the current controversial design (my personal feelings set aside) or the coalition promoted Champlain RIGHTway (Pine Street Coalition, Vermont Racial Justice Alliance and Fortieth Burlington, LLC [Innovation Center]). (Not to say the RIGHTway coalition of three groups are truly all ears for any grassroots suggestions!!) While most have an opinion about roundabouts or at least know about them, few have given much thought to the City’s Department of Public Works (DPW) increasing use of RRFB’s (Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacons) installed mostly without even bothering to do much analysis of intersection management choices. So about 2013 or early 2014 during the Mayor Weinberger administration the first RRFBs were installed along Pine Street. I call them fireflies because along Pine Street at night where there are several one sees them light up sporadically like fireflies. In part because there is no clear priority for pedestrian safety in the City (its’s the apartheid mode remember) not much attention has been given to the RRFB versus the acknowledged safest pedestrian intersection which is the all-way-stop, versus the traffic light which is the true enemy of the pedestrian.

Defining the differences, particularly in regard to safety, is important even if one does not care about pedestrian since the City has about a third of its traffic high crash intersections, with our a quarter, 20, on the current VTrans high crash intersection list—those intersections average 1.5 injuries a year. Our five downtown VT roundabouts average one injury a decade (0 bike injuries in 52 years recorded and one pedestrian non-serious injury). Burlington experiences about two car occupants a week and one either a cyclist or a pedestrian injury (2012-2016 data). The RRFB The RRFB started as proprietary product and owed much of its success to a great extent from advertising and public relations activity (something roundabouts and all-way-stops lack!). 

 Traffic engineers for three generations have lived off traffic signals installations and their management—many without much knowledge of RRFB performance have apparently succumbed to their allure—and cheapness, about a tenth the cost of a traffic signal (about $175,000 median price). What do we know about the RRFB? The 2008 first research mostly centered on its first use for mid-block crossings—BTV is doing this too. A more recent study, 2020 is fairly comprehensive but still centers on mid-block or mid-block with a significant private entry: https://www.oregon.gov/odot/Programs/ResearchDocuments/SPR814Final.pdf As an aside, it would nice if DPW began to seek research and analytical support in their decision making. Too much of Burlington transportation—Regional Planning too but to a lesser extent, staff as well as consultants—remains cookbook and ignoring major changes, sometimes rapid like bicycle treatments evolution at roundabouts, now proceeding. 

What we should ask and demand is transportation investments based not just on comprehensive cost benefit (sill in its infancy here in Vermont), but also on the “science,” transportation research. In a word we need a Fauci overview, the science, in our transport decisions. The 2020 Racism as a Public Health Emergency and 2019 Climate Change Emergency, both new City policies, must be afforded more than check the box response at DPW and CCRPC. So, privately promoted RRFBs are new, little research is available, particularly on use at intersections. It is true that mid-block crossing use may have benefit cost benefits versus very expensive ($1 million on up) HAWK and Pelican treatments—which do better than RRFBs but not when benefit cost is involved—still a tradeoff of cost for pedestrian injuries which is still involves careful thoughtful decision. RRFBs at the Locust St intersection.   First, the Pine Street RRFB intersection treatments apply mostly to crossing Pine Street but not along Pine crossings themselves—i.e., Marble, Locust, Howard marked crosswalks. Second, we have no thorough research on RRFB versus the normal and equally highest level of safety all-way-stop and roundabout. We must analyze alternatives because single-lane roundabout with central islands can be quite expensive, but mini roundabouts (recommended up and down Pine Street by Dan Burden in the AARP 2014 Pine Street Workshop report with preliminary feasibility designs provided for Pine/Maple Street intersection on page 1) can be quite cheap and obviously superior in safety (and most everything else!). Consider the fact that within the first few months of installation, there was a critical pedestrian injury at the Locust Street/Pine Street RRFB—more serious than any pedestrian injury (the one!) in a half century of downtown VT roundabouts tabulated. One critical injury does not mean we should reject RRFBs, but it jogs the mind and connects the new roundabout at one end of Locust, the mini recommendation of Dan Burden (58th on the list of great urbanists in recorded time) for every intersection south of Main Street, and, yes, the very fact the intersection has been unaddressed in the Champlain Parkway over half a century.

So, first, does an all-way-stop make sense at Locust/Pine as that is the traditional traffic engineer correctly staged most safe for pedestrians. Actually we have an all-way-stop at both Pine/Maple and Pine/King about seven blocks away—it is safe for the many pedestrians (most students using to access school buses a.m. and p.m. are persons of color). And yes, there is no anecdotal of pedestrian crashes there. But for sure anyone who travels, works, or lives along Pine Street knows at traditional drive time p.m. experience regular 4-7 minutes queues to clear the Maple Street intersection northbound. That would likely be duplicated for the downtown bound stream at Locust as well. The alternative roundabout here because of tight space, the mini-roundabout. First, Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) lists the roundabout as the only pedestrian safety “proven countermeasure” and is the only intersection type on the list—FHWA might consider adding the all-way-stop to pedestrian proven safety countermeasure list. Yes, Roundabouts at Each End of Locust Street Since an all-way-stop means unacceptable addition at busy intersections of more queuing with vehicle delay and increased climate heating in violation of our 2019 Climate Change Emergency policy—the roundabout becomes the default choice—which in addition to pedestrian safety equal to the all-way-stop (signals FHWA tells us generate a 20% higher pedestrian crash rate than either all way or rounds) also results in sharply lower crash rates for vehicles, reductions in climate change emissions and pollutants, drops in vehicle delay and motor fuel consumption, lower maintenance cost and not eventual replacement costs (signals have a limited lifespan, even RRFBs), improved scenic quality, and certainly some safety benefit for cyclists if only through traffic calming of speeds two-three blocks in all directions. 

 At Locust/Pine most of the land, at least on three quadrants of publicly owned (the Park and either City and/or Burlington Electric Department on the westside assure no right-of-way acquisition issues. So, the costs of a mini-roundabout would be low and development time a few weeks of design and public review process followed by construction in the next normal season—usually installing (like at Shelburne Street Roundabout) in June after both elementary schools are closed. Price would be mid-five figures likely. Certainly for costs, comparing mini to RRFB, the roundabout wins easily. So let’s proceed with a scoping of a mini-roundabout at Pine/Locust and provide the safest street in the City with a roundabout at either end?—for a lengthy roundabout dogbone round duo!! RRFBs at Shelburne Street Roundabout? Why? For some reason RRFBs are to be installed at the Shelburne Street Roundabout in spite of the fact that not a single pedestrian has every died on the 9,000 US/Canadian roundabouts on a marked crosswalk through 2020 (two deaths on marked Burlington the roughly 75 traffic signal crosswalks since1998). 

If one were concerned about improving pedestrian safety at a roundabout which cuts serious or fatal injury upwards of 90% there are certainly better, cheaper engineering choices one would be expected to take. First, one could narrow entries/exits to 10 feet (see Keck Circle in Montpelier or Grand Union in Manchester Center) versus the practice of VTrans of 12-15 feet wide entry and exit lanes. In other words, reduce area of pedestrian exposure—a principle often and thankfully employed by our DPW. No costs involved but certainly some resulting reduced speeds beneficial to pedestrian safety. Second, one could employ raised crosswalks which has been done in a few cases elsewhere. Again, no cost. The problem is if you get roughly about a 90% average decline in pedestrian safety, then additional expenditures need to be carefully considered and not controversial. Narrowing entries and raised crosswalks do not engender anything negative. A signal without some scientific support? Raises serious concern the signal could increase ped injury rate. RRFBs which are not the best practice at an intersection and where there is no science to support it, is very questionable at a roundabout (why at a roundabout, for example, but not at an equally performing safe intersection type, the all-way-stop?). I myself avoid where I possibly can ever using an RRFB at an intersection, instead of venture carefully onto a crosswalk, making sure a vehicle driver sees me and yields, then halfway across repeat with traffic in the opposite direction. The reason? Like at a roundabout (sans signals) its safety depends not only by design (medians restricting crossing to one direction of traffic at a time, vehicle speed constraints) but also by making safe crossing include an alert pedestrian self-protecting and a driver yielding—neither with any distraction like a signal. Those are absent at a traffic signal—any traffic signal which interferes with accountability of driver and pedestrian, therefore accounting for the relatively poor signal pedestrian performance and the superior roundabout pedestrian performance. 

     Locust/Pine Roundabout and Bicyclists

Right now the Locust/Pine intersection provides no treatments applicable to the bicyclists. The Locust/Pine roundabout would provide significant safety improvements. First, a standard ramp—off on approach and ramp-on at the outgoing leg would be provided—same as at the Shelburne Street Roundabout. This “choice” of take the roundabout lane or shift to pedestrian mode and benefit from the safer pedestrian crossings is a safety improvement over the current configuration. The cyclist entering Pine Street from Locust clearly gains as a stop is no longer necessary, reduced speed conditions mean easier integration to traffic, etc. For bicyclists traveling south the roundabout offers an easier left turn against slowed northbound traffic and the off-on ramping now absent. 

Final Note 

My TonyRVT.blogspot.com includes a recent monograph application of roundabouts along North Street which is termed the most dangerous community street in Vermont and through adoption of mini roundabouts potentially becoming the safest. In addition there is the archive the monograph and walkability Burlington which first saw the light of day as a six part series here on the BWBC listserv.

Tony Redington September 19, 2021 TonyRVT99@gmail.com TonyRVT.blogspot.com @TonyRVT60

Friday, July 12, 2019

Burlington, VT Mayor Weinberger -- Glitter in the Gutter


Glitter in the Gutter

A guest commentary by Dr. Charles Simpson, retired SUNY Professor and Burlington, VT resident


Young, energetic, attractive in a riverboat gambler sort of way, holding developer credentials, our mayor is a man in a hurry. He promised to get things done. So what's not to like about Miro Weinberger? The persona worked once, then again. His problem now is that he didn't deliver. Not much, at least. 
We got an absurdly expensive remake of the bike/walk path, including a toxic soil fiasco that had the City storing it at a public park. He couldn't pull off a Moran Plant remake, flawed in concept to begin with: an ice climbing wall? Please. In 2006, the School District, intent in off-loading the Taft School--a structure built in 1939 by private philanthropy and $111,000 from the Works Progress Administration whose post-educational future was required to be housing for indigent men according to the Taft will, was off-loaded to UVM. Weinberger took that as a cue and tried the same trick with Memorial Auditorium, imagining it as just a fiscal liability rather than a vibrant civic arena. But the university opened the bag and found a cat instead of a pig, the cat being the absence of adequate parking. Desperate to get something done, he promised to revive the '80s circumferential highway through the South End, pretending that the public purpose of moving interstate highway traffic to the downtown core was still a viable goal. Not to worry that the highway was to end at Lake Street and the downtown has evolved away from mass shopping. Thanks to alert citizen activists, that plan is in the courts. 

Then, there's his efforts to prime the development pump with political favors. There was spot zoning to raise the height limits on three blocks of downtown as if the elaborate public process leading to Plan BTV had never happened. Add to that $22 million in forgiven future property taxes on the project. Before the project ground to a halt, leaving the present hole in the ground, Macy’s was rendered inoperable and we lost our only department store. Desperate for some achievement, he fixated on a $6 million-plus redesign of a completely serviceable public park. This grandiose "improvement" was overtly proposed as a solution to soil management issues but seems more likely to be a way to “cleans” downtown of panhandlers. This too has been stalled by civic activists, unconvinced that lighted and pulsating water jets are the attraction that tourists seek in New England. 
Then there's sins of omission. In control of the airport, our mayor could have scotched the Air Force plan to station 18 nuclear-capable fighter/bombers in the most densely settled area of the state. He “let it happen”, as he did with a financial deal with a private investor that guaranteed that our municipal telecom would pass out of public ownership.

Had Weinberger listened to authentic public input, each of these projects would have been greatly improved to public benefit. Citizens developed a much better plan for the remnant of the circumferential highway that would enhance rather than damage travel connectivity and neighborhood life. Had he listed to critics of downtown development, a reasonably-sized project would now be in the last stages of construction. Had he heard park enthusiasts, there would be a public bathroom in the downtown, maybe a shaded toddler  play area rather than another festival venue. 

There’s some changes the mayor does own. He blocked his own Parks and Recreation department's proposal to expand public moorings at the lake, refusing an associated federal grant in order to allow private investors to lease the public waterfront. Oh, and subsidizing them with $800,000 in TIF support. Yes, more than 700 units of new housing at Cambrian Rise are on the way, but that project was greased with $2 million in public funds spent to secure its lake view and front lawn. Citizen activists wanted more open land and space for wildlife. 
To a great degree, politics is a matter of projection. Voters endow candidates with their own hopes and dreams, creating an aura that reflects back on voters to make them feel good. In Burlington, we like to think our town is dynamic and innovative while delivering quality social services with the costs justly apportioned. This conviction is like a pat on the back we give ourselves. Didn’t we chose to live here? It takes a lot of government failure to chip away at this cultural capital. And for a long time we may be distracted by razzle-dazzle: "cool" electric scooters on our bike path; fireworks on July 4th; bouncing colored water jets in City Hall Park. But now its the morning after Mardi Gras. The only razzle-dazzle we can see is some glitter in the gutter.

Wednesday, June 5, 2019

A, B and C of Safe Modern Busy Street Design

Note: The U.S. dropped from first to 20th in highway safety since 1990 with today about 22,000 excess fatalities and hundreds of thousands of serious injuries each year compared to the numbers generated per mile of travel by the average of the top four nations--the UK (we were tied with them in 1990 for #1), Norway, Sweden and Switzerland.  AAA studies point to desperate need for U.S. to address its shoddy highway safety status.  AAA, AARP, Federal Highway Administration and Geico all support roundabouts for safety and converting signals to roundabouts for reducing serious and fatal injuries. 


The A, B and C of Modern Busy Urban Street Design:
the Burlington, VT Example
--yes, there are D, E, F, etc. to be covered in future analyses

Since 2000 a revolution occurred in United States modern busy urban streets design. Today there are three generic elements necessary when choosing to serve safely those who walk, bicycle, and, yes, those who travel by car on a busy urban street.

The three core busy urban street design elements are:
  1. sidewalk
  2. roundabout
  3. cycle track (protected bike lane)
The basic design principle? Safety first!

If your busy urban street lacks one or more of these three central components—or their equivalent--by definition one or more ways of travel is unsafe, undeserviced and/or less than the desired, complete transportation street.

In many cases geographic (sharp grades like San Francisco hills), physical constraints (older narrow streets), etc., prevent fully achieving all three elements. The three elements remain the desired objective for safety! The 1000 Friends of Portland study found, essentially, the formula to walkable busy streets are a sidewalk network free of sharp grades plus ease of crossing intersections only the roundabout enables safely.

Almost by default by a neighborhood driven planning process, the Burlington, VT adopted its North Avenue Corridor Plan in 2014 where these three elements were enshrined to provide the highest level of safety for all modes: an existing sidewalk system, cycle track from end to end of the 2.6 mile corridor, and conversion of three of seven busy intersection traffic signals to roundabouts. Note the report two-page Chapter 1 vision and goals: https://studiesandreports.ccrpcvt.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/FINAL-NorthAve_CorridorReport.pdf

The roundabout, birthed in the U.K. in 1966, arrived in the U.S. in 1990. By 2005 NY State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) made the roundabout which cuts serious and fatal injuries about 90% its standard based on better safety for all modes. At U.S. and Canadian roundabouts, about 10,000 today, only one pedestrian and two cyclist fatalities occurred to date. NYSDOT's 2005 action instantly fossilized the traffic signal in America. (Consider the Assam, NL design preferred by many in the U.S. with a separate walk and bike lane: https://www.google.com/search?hs=ylX&q=assam+roundabout+design+netherlands&tbm=isch&source=univ&client=opera&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiYqdO8_s_iAhVkRN8KHbZODNIQsAR6BAgFEAE&biw=784&bih=462 )

Historically cycle track is the newest and most rapidly adopted generic street element—the first cycle track network in North America being installed in Montreal in 2007.
Cycle track adoption here includes its appearance statewide bike plans like the first Illinois state bicycle plan in 2014 and by 2017 in the form of a cycle track network in
Burlington, VT's planBTV Walk Bike: https://www.burlingtonvt.gov/planbtvwalkbike The “old” bicycle provisions of paint on street may have been help to the then prevalent young adult male cyclists. But paint on streets excluded most less skilled, old and young, and women concerned with personal safety. Simply, paint on asphalt is not a safety device and offers minimal safety benefit compared to cycle track while leaving most of the potential bicycle riding community unwilling to ride two wheelers.

Yes, there are some additional wrinkles. Led by Vermont bikepath pioneer, now Dr. Anne Lusk, Harvard School of Public Health, the cycle track alternative location on sidewalk level where there are business or other mixed use areas emerged. Dr. Lusk led the first safety studies showing the superior safety performance of cycle track in Montreal early this decade. Here is the 2010 Lusk study report: https://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/17/2/131

Japan cities feature widespread use of sidewalk level cycle track (though only now adopting roundabout technology). Bicycling is a natural part of Japanese urban neighborhood travel activity (and connecting to subways in major cities) with pedestrians and cyclists of all ages mixing in a low speed cycling context on sidewalk spaces and street crossings. (Up to 10% of Japanese bicycles are E-bikes.)

Among other features, sidewalk level cycle track favors adjacent businesses with easier access and added flexible space between the business and vehicle travelways. Cycle track not on vehicle travelway may be at sidewalk level or at a separate level between the sidewalk level and vehicle travelway. Sidewalk cycle track examples:

There are a few other variations in street design of note, particularly “shared space” where all modes mix, coexist in a low speed and safe context https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shared_space One reason busy street urban Japan cycle track works so well is the presence of shared space neighborhood “local” side streets as described in the Wikipedia entry.

These major changes in safe busy urban street design took place since 1990 when the U.S. began its drop from 1st to 20th in highway fatality rates, now 22,000 yearly excess highway deaths compared to the average of the top four, the U.K. (co-leader with U.S. in 1990), Norway, Sweden and Switzerland. Safety first!


Tony Redington  June 7, 2019

TonyRVT99@gmail.com @TonyRVT60 TonyRVT.Blogspot.com

Wednesday, January 10, 2018

A Housing Policy for Burlington and State of Vermont--A Three Pronged Interim Policy Approach


Following discussions and exploration over the past year, I have been working on further policy analysis to seek a “one fits all policy” to deal with the radical changes in the Burlington, Chittenden County, and Vermont housing market. Part of the housing assistance needs involves folding in populations left out of the dominant federal programs particularly lower income senior homeowners as well as acute housing needs of falling through the cracks in the Department of Corrections, the Department of Mental Health, our hospitals, and the obvious needs of the homeless.

The lack of a unifying housing policy at all levels, the need for State/local funding starting with the Governor's Poverty Council recommendation for the $2 a night lodging fee as a funding source, and finally, recognizing the value as well as limitation of current State efforts using non-profit housing agencies—all are summarized in a three part policy which is hereby recommended as a starting point for discussion for all to consider and support.

Below please find a general background piece to the short brief policy, attached.



Prefatory Note:
At two major Burlington housing developments in process--311 apartments in Sinex's Town Center and Cambrian Rise 735 apartments which total over 1,000—not a single homeless person or very low income household receives “affordable housing assistance” (federal very low income limit for a family of three, $37,100).
Any “affordable housing assistance”--30% of household income maximum for  rent—for the homeless and very low income gets drawn almost completely from the existing Vermont pool of federal units. The 20%+ in these two projects of “inclusionary zoning” (IZ) apartments priced--for example at $1,200 monthly for a 2-bedroom--mostly serve middle income households which includes just the upper range of $49,000 to $59,000 income for a family of three in the federal “low income” schedule for Burlington metro area.

(Note $59,000 income is about 80% of the median income for 3-person families, the upper level for federal "affordable housing assistance" [AHA].)



Introduction and Larger Background



Attached please find a draft wording of a three-part universal housing policy, an interim “no regrets” vehicle, which directly addresses a Burlington and State need for an “affordable housing assistance” (AHA) program built around a $2 nightly lodging fee.

The lack of a clear State or Burlington housing policy makes informed discussion very difficult. A policy analyst must scramble to find available key data in a radically changed housing market from even three years ago. The housing market itself and needs change as the housing market emerged from the Great Recession and building began in earnest about 2015 while federal housing dollars stagnation over the past decade now demands Burlington and Vermont state programming to meet unrelenting needs.

At the State level housing needs policies rests on data sources of 2014 and prior. Since that time in Burlington alone boasts about 3,000 apartments built or well into development which expands the rental housing over 30% (for examples over 1,000 units alone in Burlington Town Center and Cambrian Rise). Since 2015 the decades long 1-2% rental vacancy rates suddenly escalated in the City and solidly reside at or above a healthy 3-5% range of the total rental inventory. ( For the data base of current State policies see p 9 footnote 3 http://accd.vermont.gov/sites/accdnew/files/documents/2017%20Housing%20Budget%20and%20Investments%20Report.pdf )

Basic housing needs in Chittenden County have shifted from a lack of supply of housing and affordability to the single track need for “affordable housing assistance” (AHA). “Affordable housing assistance” means in federal and housing community language a home where rent or ownership costs consume no more than 30% of household income. In Vermont there are 13,000 units of “affordable housing assistance”--about one in six renters benefiting—primarily in the form of federal Section 8, Public Housing and “Housing Choice Vouchers” administered by our State and local housing authorities.

Why is Housing Different?

Housing for Vermont families differs from food and medical care, both entitlements ultimately guaranteed now by federal programs and monies. Housing remains a scramble for limited “affordable housing assistance” (AHA) and the twin need, lack of household protection from loss of housing from changed economic circumstances also provided in “affordable housing assistance,” i.e., a decline in income is matched by a decreased rent. Today there are no significant State and local AHA programs.
The roughly 2,000 on waiting lists today in Chittenden County and Burlington for what assistance is available testifies to that fact that affordable housing assistance is a critical and unaddressed need. More importantly with stagnant incomes for three decades now and cost of housing relatively higher, housing—already the biggest cost in the typical household budget—can no longer be ignored in State and City human service programming. Today a new element is added, the presence of ever increasing numbers of senior homeowners on fixed incomes unable to age in place. Something must be done.

The Dollar Dimensions

The State of Vermont housing programs provide very little AHA. The 13,000 AHA units in Vermont represent a $104 million in federal funds. In 2017 other federal assistance like Community Development Block Grants and homeownership subsidy amounted to $8.6 million. State fragmented housing assistance initiatives—very little long term AHA—amounts at most to $10 million.

The attached brief “background” and three basic policies provides a starting point for discussion and three interim policy directions until a through State and City policy development process takes place. We cannot even begin to address housing needs without a stable and significant amount of funding. A City initiative might fund 5 to 15 units pilot of “affordable housing assistance” (AHA)--equal in cost to a single professional position at City Hall. A State program, already recommended by the Governor's Pathways from Poverty in 2016 and considered at last session, consists of a $2 nightly lodging fee mostly paid by out-of-state visitors which would fund over 1,000 units of “affordable housing assistance” (AHA).

A State AHA program also directly addresses a number of existing patchwork housing efforts provided by hospitals, the prison system, and the mental health agencies—three major government areas where housing is being provided in the community so the key organizations can avoid the huge financial burden of in-facility service because no AHA is available. The Department of Mental Health, Department of Corrections and hospitals hold individuals at great expense who only need a place to live with AHA support at a cost of about $9,000 yearly versus $62,000 for a Vermont prisoner with hospital stays of all type well above.

The three policies call for:
1. carrying out a State and City housing policy plan process
2. starting a statewide program of “affordable housing assistance” (AHA) employing a $2 a night lodging fee serving over 1,000 low income households, senior homeowners and renters in need, and the homeless
3. continued support for housing development through “inclusionary zoning” practice by Burlington and housing development by non-profit housing agencies like Champlain Housing Trust and senior/disabled houser Cathedral Corporation. Unless paired some or all “affordable housing assistance” these programs serve almost exclusively moderate and middle income households.




THE ATTACHMENT:

1/7/2018 Draft


A Universal Vermont and Burlington City Housing Policy Statement

Background:

Federal entitlement programs today insuring all households basic food security and health care. But no Federal “affordable housing assistance” (AHA) entitlement program exists. Federal truly “affordable housing assistance” is limited here in Vermont to 13,000 low income and disabled rental households—about one in six renters. Popularly known as Public Housing, Section 8 and Housing Choice Vouchers, “affordable housing assistance” (AHA) defined by the U.S. government means a household pays at most 30% of income for housing with rent adjusted downward if income declines. “Affordable housing assistance” is by design a “livable rent or ownership” also providing “shelter security” for recipients who know a sudden change in income does not threaten shelter loss. Truly “affordable housing assistance” remains a huge unmet need.

There exists no expectation the federal programs will expand to meet State and local needs. Both homeowners and renters face housing affordability challenge and any program must address both. The rapidly growing number of senior homeowners on fixed income pose a new concern as this group cannot be served by current programs. In Burlington alone over 1,000 wait on lists for existing “affordable housing assistance” and Cathedral Corporation serving seniors and the disabled in Chittenden County waiting lists tops 700 applicants seeking Federal “affordable housing assistance” or non-profit moderate income housing.

Three Overarching Policies for Today

  1. Establish a clear and comprehensive set of (City) (State) housing policies and measurable objectives focused on the low income and the disabled

  1. Dedicate funds from a State $2 nightly lodging fee to create an “affordable housing assistance” program based on need for low income seniors and families as well as disabled Vermonters (30% of household income maximum adjusted if income declines). This program includes a homeowner component.

  1. Advance non-profit and other housing development public policies and programs benefiting moderate income Vermonters.

A base document outlining Vermont housing information and programs: “2017 Vermont Housing Budget and Investment Report” Vermont Department of Housing and Community Development http://accd.vermont.gov/sites/accdnew/files/documents/2017%20Housing%20Budget%20and%20Investments%20Report.pdf

Monday, January 4, 2016

Cleansing Burlington's "dirty 17" high per crash locations with roundabouts

1/3/2016 Revision 1


Cleaning the “Dirty 17” Burlington, VT One-a-Year Pedestrian Injury Intersections to About One a Decade Average with Roundabouts--Opportunities and Costs

Summary

As analyzed here, cleansing 15 of the “dirty 17” Burlington intersections averaging one pedestrian injury a year occurs by converting them to roundabouts. After conversion pedestrian crashes would drop from15 pedestrian injuries a year now to one or two a year. The 90% reduction in pedestrian crashes prediction is based on single lane roundabout research and the recent tabulation of 52 years of Vermont downtown/town center roundabouts history which recorded just a single non-serious pedestrian injury. Two of the “dirty 17” intersections—one during the 2011-2014 data collected in the Walk Bike Master Plan study now under way and one in 1998—recorded a pedestrian fatality. The 2015 measure of the value of a life saved used by the Federal Highway Administration is $9.4 million. A recent value of a highway injury used in a American Automobile Association study (Cambridge Systematics) was $126,000.

Introduction

The Burlington Walk Bike Master Plan identifies 17 intersections averaging one (0.9) pedestrian injuries per year for the four years 2011-2014. Just now safety performance data on of five downtown Vermont roundabouts found one pedestrian injury (not serious) over a span of 52 years of roundabout operation history through late 2015. The Burlington “dirty 17” record includes a fatal injury and at least one critically injury. Since roundabout research indicates a 90% reduction in pedestrian injuries at single lane roundabouts compared to signs and signals, “cleaning” the “dirty 17” in Burlington with single lane roundabouts reduces frequency of pedestrian crashes to one per decade and decreases injury severity as well. Of the 17 intersections all but perhaps two—requiring two lane roundabouts—are single lane roundabout candidates. Note, single lane roundabouts research conclusively finds single lane roundabouts deceasing serious and fatal car occupant injuries by 90%, and research finds single lane roundabouts for cyclists reaches towards the 90% reduction of injuries if a separate path or ramp off/on to join with pedestrians for crossings is provided.

Vermont's Montpelier Keck Circle first roundabout in the northeast (19th in the U.S.) in 1995 and Grand Union Roundabout in Manchester Center in 1997 by chance are two of the earliest downtown/town center roundabouts in the U.S. and Canada. Now along with two more roundabouts in Manchester Center and the Main Street Roundabout in Middlebury, this group of five become first to reach 52 years of service with both significant volumes of pedestrians but also an ongoing tabulation of pedestrian accident data. The Vermont downtown roundabout performance does not come as a total surprise as international research finds about a 90% reduction in pedestrian injuries at single lane roundabouts like Vermont's. Still, the Vermont downtown roundabout safety performance of one minor pedestrian injury in 52 years stands in sharp relief opposite to the Burlington “dirty 17” recording one pedestrian crash per year 2011-2014 with one fatality and at least one critical injury.

The question can be asked “what if” the pedestrian “dirty 17” intersections in Burlington were converted to a roundabout, what would be the costs? Using the rule of thumb of a 90% reduction of pedestrian injuries of roundabouts over signed or signalized intersections, the 17 injuries a year at the Burlington intersection would drop to less than two per year. The U.S. sinking from first to 19th in highway safety with over 40% of the 30,000 annual deaths prevented by reaching top nations in highway safety, this analysis is far more than a theoretical exercise. Further in the last decade as more walk and bike--”healthy transportation”--walk and bike fatalities have plateaued and even increased, and have become a higher proportion of overall highway fatalities as both modes vulnerability in crashes with vehicles is obvious and practically impossible to alter in a significant way.

The following analysis makes these assumptions;

  1. Any consideration of roundabouts at a high accident location—like the “dirty 17”-- requires a full engineering study involving an experienced roundabout designer. (Vermont remains one of the rare states where almost all the long time roundabout practitioners have either presented workshops in the State or done design work here—in some cases both.)
  2. At some point—the sooner the better--high accident intersections in Burlington will be evaluated for roundabout or other major safety upgrade, and a list of intersections will be prioritized—ditto for Chittenden County which lacks a single safe roundabout intersection on a busy public street.
  3. The cost assumptions here are that the projects will be done without use of federal funding. Costs would be roughly 75% higher with the involvement of federal funds. Where federal funds are known to be involved (Shelburne Street Roundabout and Champlain Parkway intersections) a “federal” estimate is provided.
  4. Mini-roundabouts can be built with very low costs. A high-end figure of $50,000 will be used in these estimates.
  5. All estimates are those of the author based on experience—they are “ballpark” only and can only be refined by engineering studies.
  6. All intersections would include separate walk and bike treatment or, mostly likely given constraints, off/on ramping to give a cyclist the choice of “taking the circulating travelway” or “ramping off” onto shared pedestrian space, proceeding across crosswalk(s) before “ramping on” to the street to continue on (this is the Shelbune Street Roundabout design at Shelburne/Locust/So. Willard set for construction in 2021, possibly earlier).

Estimated Total Costs for Roundabouts

The total cost estimates provided below of $39 million for 15 of the intersections exclude the possible treatments which may include a roundabout for the North Street/Murray Street node and the “area” identified in the Walk Bike Master Plan between Intervale Road and Hill Street node. The estimates for three of the intersections are for mini-roundabouts with an estimated cost of $50,000 ear. Note there are 75 signalized intersections in Burlngton and 11 conversions to roundabouts are contained in the estimates here. The North Avenue Corridor Plan includes conversion of another three signals to roundabouts. The $39 million cost for 15 roundabouts compares to the $43 million current cost estimate for the Champlain Parkway. Using a cost factor of 1.75 for federally built roundabouts (other than the three given in federal estimates, that is Pine/Locust, Pine/Lakeside and the Rotary Roundabout) the total for the 15 roundabouts is $60 million.

Roundabouts tend to score very well against alternative transportation investments in benefit cost analyses in great part because of substantial reductions in crashes (50 percent), injuries and injury severity, and low maintenance costs. In addition, roundabouts cut fuel consumption by about a third compared to signals, pollution and global warming gases by a similar amount compared to signal, sharply reduce delay for all users and provide 50 to 100% greater capacity for cars. Obviously the roundabout features a higher level of scenic quality.

Outline of Possible Roundabout Treatments for Burlington's 17 High Pedestrian Injury intersections

Note again the following 17 intersections evaluation proceeds without consideration to priority or connection with other planned City intersections except for the Parkway intersections of Pine/Locust, Pine/Lakeside and the “Shelburne Street Roundabout” (Shelburne/Locust/South Willard)--all currently scheduled for funding in committed projects and therefore are considered fully funded.
  1. North Winooski/South Winooski (North Winooski/Pearl), South Winooski/Cherry, South Winooski/Bank, South Winooski College, and South Winooski/Main)
These five intersections represent the only “corridor” where all show up on the high pedestrian crash list. This corridor and Battery Street are the only two-way north/south through streets serving the Marketplace. The Burlington Town Center plan to connect Pine Street again from Pearl Street southward through the Town Center would move a significant amount of vehicle traffic off South Winooski (and some off Battery Streets). Roundabout treatments need to be part of a corridor (Pearl to Main) approach of five roundabouts developed together as a package over a period of time as each relates directly to the performance of adjacent roundabouts. The improved connectivity from a Pine Street re-connection would result in traffic reduction on South Winooski would perhaps change some of the challenges for roundabouts along South Winooski intersections.

North Winooski/Pearl

Treatment: This intersection presents the most difficult challenge along South Winooski. Only the southwest quadrant presents the possibility of a roundabout. Roundabouts do can be off center in an intersection. Still a major traffic calming treatment is required to reduce pressure on the Church/Pearl mid-block crossing. Cost: $3 million (if feasible).
South Winooski/Cherry

Treatment: A single lane roundabout can be fashioned with use of institutional right-of-way to the east and possibility a slight amount from the Rite Aid site (Rite Aide gets the benefit of a possible direct entry onto the roundabout). Also the resolution of revamping North Winooski/Pearl and South Winooski/Bank ties directly to design for this intersection. Estimated cost: $3 million


South Winooski/Bank Street

Treatment: Utilizing the likely moving or closure of both gas stations at the west corners of the intersections as high level economic value uses take over these two sites, space can be reserved allowing an easy installation of a one lane roundabout which would also benefit the developments occupying the space of the former gas stations. Estimated cost: $3 million

South Winooski/College
Treatment: Right-of-way restrictions from three of four corner buildings (also narrowest width between east and west buildings on South Winooski between Pearl and Main) only allow consideration of a mini-roundabout. Again, a mini-roundabout needs to be part of an overall set of intersection treatments from Pearl to Main. Since even with current traffic levels a “road diet” has been suggested, such a change would augur well for a mini-roundabout feasibility. Estimated cost: $0.5 million.

South Winooski/Main
Treatment: Likely the only intersection requiring a two-lane roundabout with pedestrian actuated signals designed primarily for those with severe visual disability. Also the most expensive roundabout. Estimated cost: $6.0 million

2. Shelburne Street “Rotary” at Locust/South Willard

Treatment: “Shelburne Street Roundabout”, single lane, 100% federally funded safety project scheduled to be completed sometime during 2018-2021. Chittenden County Regional Planning Commission (CCRPC) “Transportation Improvement Program FY 2014-2017.” Total Estimated cost: $2.9 million (100% of funding from federal sources already allocated)

      1. Archibald/Intervale Ave
Treatment: This four-way stop intersection clearly lends itself to a mini-roundabout treatment. The skewed character of this intersection does present some design challenges. Estimated cost: $50,000

      1. Riverside—Intervale Rd to Hillside Ave
Treatment: This “area” with four pedestrian injuries may be better served by traffic calming and other related treatments. A serious bike injury—typical of multi-use paths at signals—occurred at the Riverside/Intervale Rd intersection as a cyclist crashed into a car with a green light entering Intervale Rd from Riverside—establishing a barrier/buffer to force cyclists to come to a stop or a roundabout for the intersection might be possible. Treatments to be determined after an engineering study. Estimated cost: No estimate at this time.
5. North Street at Murray
Treatment: The Walk Bike Master Plan suggestion for this “area” is a “shared space” concept. Such a design could very well include a circular paving area at Murray where vehicles would enter/exit Murray in a “roundabout manner.” This approach has been used in European applications. Estimated cost: No regular roundabout to be used.

6. North Winooski/North
Treatment: This fully signalized intersection with pedestrian actuation can be covered to a mini-roundabout. With four commercial/retail buildings on each corner the intersection does generate a significant amount of foot traffic. Estimated cost: $50,000

7. Loomis/North Prospect
Treatment: This two-way stop control intersection can be converted into a mini-roundabout which will traffic calm Prospect, a busy minor arterial street. Estimated cost: $50,000
  1. Main/St. Paul
Treatment: This intersection adjacent to City Hall Park was the site of a high speed chase involving police and the miscreant driver whose vehicle T-boned a vehicle driven by Kaye Borneman, a Dealer.com employee. “Normal” roundabouts with central islands virtually eliminate the T-bone crash—and roundabouts when installed in downtowns and town centers also make high speed chases difficult and interception by law enforcement easy at the nearest roundabout. With the availability of some public land a normal roundabout may be feasible at this intersection or if not feasible a mini-roundabout is indicated. Estimated cost: $3 million

9. Pine/Lakeside Ave
Treatment: This signal intersection along the Parkway route will experience considerable increase in traffic volume with the Parkway completed as now designed. With a coffee shop, Department of Public Works main office facility and a gas/convenience store bordering, some design challenges exist. But relatively open area at the gas/convenience store site—perhaps it will have direct roundabout entry--makes it very likely a workable roundabout design is feasible. While the City is spending about $420,000 of local funds currently for a signal upgrade, the City costs for a roundabout as part of the Parkway would be 2% of an estimated total cost of $5 million as a federally funded project or $100,000.
Estimated cost: $5 million
10. Colchester/Barrett
Treatment: This intersection is part of a complex of streets requiring a larger design solution—very likely at least two single lane roundabouts. Colchester/Barrett and Colchester/Riverside Ave intersections are closely related, and Riverside also has a spur easterly enabling vehicles to cross between it and Barrett. Overall the overhaul of these two intersections along with Mill Street, a T intersection between the Colchester/Riverside/Barrett connections to the north and a few feet from the bridge to Winooski, may lead to making Mill Street one-way westerly with an outlet onto Barrett. Roundabouts would enable such a circulation solution. With likely retaining walls and other structural needs to accommodate a satisfactory engineering solution, an estimated cost may well climb to about $8 million. For purposes here, $4 million will be allocated as the cost responsibility for Colchester/Barrett. Estimated cost: $4 million


11. Colchester/East Ave
Treatment: Colchester/East Ave presents perhaps the easiest normal roundabout opportunity with publicly owned land on three quadrants and no right-of-way constrictions on on the west side of Colchester Ave.
Estimated cost: $2 million
12. Pine/Locust
Treatment: A critical injury at this intersection occurred a few months after installing a Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFB) for crossing Pine Street only. A single lane roundabout is feasible at this intersection because of the availability of right-of-way on the west side of Pine from property owned by BED. This intersection would likely be upgraded as part do a “corridor of roundabouts” including Pine/Howard and Pine/Lakeside intersections converted to roundabouts (up to 10 or more roundabouts conceivable along the Parkway). The cost of this intersection for the City will be estimated at 2% of $3 million (federal project cost) as part of the Parkway project, or $60,000. Estimated cost: $3 million

13. Shelburne/Home
Treatment: This intersection definitely requires a two-lane roundabout and along with South Winooski/Main (possibly) represent the only two multi-lane roundabouts among the 17 intersections. Still, Shelburne/Home will experience some decline with the opening of part or all of the Parkway, conceivably decreasing the traffic to the point a single lane roundabout suffices. Linda Ente during a trip work at Price Chopper was killed on the crosswalk at this intersection in 1998. Estimated cost: $4 million





Tony Redington
@TonyRVT08
TonyRVT.blogspot.com